Daniel Penny acquitted for chokehold death of Jordan Neely on New York City subway

A New York Metropolis jury has acquitted 26-year-old Daniel Penny for the 2023 demise of Jordan Neely, a homeless man with psychological well being points who Penny put right into a chokehold for practically six minutes throughout a tense encounter on the subway.

The jury cleared Penny of criminally negligent murder in Neely’s demise. A extra critical manslaughter cost was dismissed earlier in deliberations as a result of the jury deadlocked on that rely. Each prices have been felonies and carried the opportunity of jail time.

Each applause and anger broke out within the courtroom because the not-guilty verdict got here in. Neely’s father was escorted out of the courtroom after an “audible outburst with expletives,” based on CNN.

One other individual additionally left, wailing with tears.

Penny, who had proven little expression through the trial, briefly smiled as the decision was learn.

The not-guilty verdict was praised by Republican New York Metropolis councilwoman Joann Ariola, who stated “justice has prevailed.”

“Daniel Penny is a hero, and I’m joyful to see {that a} good man was not punished for doing the precise factor and defending his fellow New Yorkers from a mentally sick felony who fell between the cracks,” Ariola stated.

open picture in gallery

“Excellent news for NYC: Daniel Penny has been acquitted,” Democratic council member Robert Holden stated in an announcement on X. “Justice has been served for a U.S. Marine who bravely stepped as much as defend fellow New Yorkers throughout a second of hazard.

“This end result highlights the necessity to deal with actual options, like addressing untreated psychological sickness, to forestall future tragedies like this from occurring once more.”

Metropolis councilman Yusef Salaam, a member of the Central Park 5 who was wrongfully convicted, stated the decision represented “a searing indictment” of “systemic failures.”

“His killing underscores the pressing and overdue want for an entire overhaul in how we handle psychological well being crises and homelessness,” Salaam stated.

Talking outdoors of courtroom, Neely’s father stated his son “didn’t should undergo this” in an emotional assertion.

“It hurts. actually actually hurts. What are we gonna do, folks? What’s gonna occur to us now? I’ve had sufficient of this. The system is rigged. Let’s do one thing about this.”

The trial, which started in October, centered on whether or not Penny, an structure pupil and Marine Corps veteran, was justified in utilizing probably deadly drive on Neely through the Could 1, 2023, incident.

Witnesses described Neely, a road performer, getting into the subway automobile and yelling threateningly to passengers that he didn’t have meals and water and didn’t care if he went to again to jail. Penny, in addition to a few of his fellow passengers, claimed Neely additionally stated he was prepared to kill.

Prosecutors argued Penny’s preliminary try to defend his fellow passengers was comprehensible and “even laudable,” however that the coed went too far and used deadly drive unnecessarily. They argued he continued to choke Neely after some passengers exited the practice and Neely stopped shifting for practically a minute.

“You clearly can not kill somebody as a result of they’re loopy and ranting and searching menacing, it doesn’t matter what it’s that they’re saying,” Manhattan Assistant District Legal professional Dafna Yoran informed jurors throughout closing arguments.

The protection, in the meantime, argued Penny’s actions have been justified by the perceived menace to the passengers on the practice.

“Daniel Penny was the one who moved to guard them,” protection legal professional Steven Raiser stated throughout closing arguments. “Why? As a result of he had one thing the others didn’t. One thing distinctive to him.”

The protection referred to as a pathologist who testified different oustide elements may have contributed to Neely’s demise, like the person’s use of artificial marijuana, his schizophrenia, and his genetic predisposition to sickle cell illnesses.

Metropolis health worker Dr. Cynthia Harris maintained throughout her testimony within the trial that Neely died from “compression of the neck,” and that “no toxicological outcome conceivable was going to vary my opinion.”

The courtroom additionally heard from a Marine Corps teacher who spoke about Penny’s coaching utilizing chokehold strategies.

open picture in gallery

The protection claims Penny sought to place Neely in a “civilian” maintain and anticipate police.

Through the trial, jurors watched video of Penny talking with police after the incident, the place he described Neely as a “crackhead” who was “appearing like a lunatic.”

“I simply wished to maintain him from attending to folks,” Penny informed police, including, “I’m not making an attempt to kill the man.”

Elsewhere, bystanders testified each that they have been relieved when Penny detained Neely, and that the Marine Corps vet ignored pleas to let the homeless man go.

Penny himself didn’t take the stand through the trial, together with his protection legal professionals saying their shopper’s statements to police adequately described the encounter.

Jury deliberation started on Tuesday, December 2.

The 12-personal panel struggled for days to succeed in a required unanimous verdict.

open picture in gallery

The choose overseeing the case allowed prosecutors on Friday (December 6) to drop the highest cost in opposition to Penny, second-degree manslaughter, clearing the way in which for the panel to think about the lesser cost of criminally negligent murder.

Within the face of the continued deliberations, Penny’s protection moved for a mistrial, a request that would’ve prompted a brand new trial with a brand new jury, however was denied.

Exterior of the felony trial, Neely’s father filed a lawsuit in opposition to Penny on Wednesday (December 4) over the subway choking, accusing the coed of negligent contact, assault, and battery that precipitated Neely’s accidents and demise.

The subway incident, by which a white man choked a Black man for minutes, rapidly turned embroiled in ongoing nationwide debates about racism, policing, and public security.

It got here within the wake of nationwide protests after Minneapolis police killed George Floyd, a Black man, in considerably related circumstances, by kneeling on his neck and again for minutes as a crowd urged them to cease.

The talk across the subway killing additionally touched a nerve about New York’s extra native points.

The town has struggled with fears about crime on the subway, criticisms of Mayor Eric Adams for a mandate to involuntarily hospitalize mentall sick homeless folks, and continued systematic failures to supply enough housing and care to unhoused folks.

Hundreds of thousands of {dollars} have been raised for Penny’s authorized protection by means of GiveSendGo, a crowdfunding platform fashionable for right-wing causes, and conservative media influencers and politicians hailed Penny as a veritable “Subway Superman,” an strange citizen taking again the streets in an unsafe, Democrat-led metropolis.

Others noticed the killing for example of white vigilantism, and New York Metropolis’s failure to take care of weak folks like Neely. His mom beforehand died in a violent crime, and Neely himself bounced out and in of jail and homeless shelters as he struggled with medication and psychological well being challenges like despair and schizophrenia.

New York Metropolis public advocate Juamaane Williams beforehand informedThe Unbiased the general public consideration across the case had created a “narrative that devalues the lifetime of a Black, homeless man with psychological well being challenges and encourages an angle of dehumanization of New Yorkers in biggest want.”

After Neely’s demise, demonstrators jumped on New York Metropolis subway tracks in protest instantly after the demise. They reprised their protest through the deliberations, changing subway adverts with indicators studying ‘A Man Was Lynched Right here,’ a reference to historic anti-lynching campaigns through the Civil Rights motion.

The Related Press contributed reporting