Best Mariah Carey Christmas Songs That Aren’t All I Want for Christmas

“Hero” could also be Carey’s best-known inspirational ballad, however the singer provided up a hopeful tune for the vacations in 2017 with “The Star,” a hovering, piano-driven monitor from the animated movie of the identical title. Impressed by the Star of Bethlehem from the nativity story, Carey urges listeners to “comply with that star above you, ought to the world attempt to break you down.”

With a heartfelt supply (and a cameo from Carey’s twins, Moroccan and Monroe within the closing seconds of the monitor), the track might have been launched for Christmas, however it’s an uplifting anthem whose message resonates yr spherical. Critics adored the soundtrack single too, with “The Star” nominated for the Greatest Authentic Track on the seventy fifth Golden Globe Awards.

Carey co-wrote this track with Harvey Mason Jr. for the soundtrack to her 2017 animated vacation movie, which follows little Mariah’s want for a pet on Christmas Day. Much like the timelessness of “All I Need for Christmas Is You,” “Lil Snowman” oozes retro enchantment, with its surf rock-inspired guitar line and Little Richard-style tinkling on the keys. Whereas Carey is best-known for her R&B stylings, “Lil Snowman” showcases a grittier aspect to her voice, which makes for a buoyant vacation hear, whereas additionally making the singer’s not-so-secret alt-rock album all of the extra intriguing.

An unique track recorded for Merry Christmas II You, Carey later re-released the R&B monitor as a duet with John Legend. Backed by a stay brass band and rollicking bass line, the track settles right into a soulful groove that lights up dinner events and vacation gatherings alike, whereas providing up a reminder to “kiss our worries and our cares away” throughout this time of yr. Whereas not as immediately catchy as a few of her different materials, “When Christmas Comes” is a gradual burn with timeless enchantment, and deserves a spot in Carey’s vacation canon.

Darlene Love might have initially sung “Christmas (Child Please Come Residence),” however Carey was the one to take it to new heights after together with the Phil Spector hit on 1994’s Merry Christmas. Now a normal in any respect her vacation reveals, Carey’s model amps up the pleading lyrics of the soulful rock tune, whereas showcasing her multi-layered voice.

And whereas Love orginally referred to as out Carey for utilizing the “Queen of Christmas” title, the legendary singer later modified her tune after Carey revealed the inspiration behind recording “Child Please Come Residence.” “I listened to that track yearly, and it was an homage to Darlene Love, the Queen of Christmas,” Carey stated, including that “[Love] can have that title without end.”

Carey teamed up together with her late mom, Patricia, on her second Christmas album for this devotional medley, which mixes “O Come All Ye Devoted” with Handel’s “Hallelujah Refrain.” Carey leads with the acquainted carol earlier than Patricia — a skilled opera singer — enters with the sacred chorus from half II of Handel’s “Messiah.”

Although Carey wrote about an at-times tumultuous relationship together with her mom in her 2020 memoir, issues are merry and shiny on this duet, with each voices mixing in good concord. Want extra proof of their mother-daughter bond? Re-watch Carey’s 2010 ABC Christmas particular, the place the 2 carried out this track collectively for the primary — and solely — time stay. As Carey closes out the monitor together with her well-known whistle register, Patricia is seen standing subsequent to her celebrity daughter, beaming with delight.

Carey wrote “Christmas Time Is within the Air Once more” with famed Broadway and movie composer Marc Shaiman, and the result’s a twinkling tune that’s good for soundtracking snowed-in days on the cabin and metropolis nights by moonlight. Although it was launched on her 2010 album, Merry Christmas II You, “Christmas Time” is a sweeping, nostalgia-tinged ballad, because of its orchestral accompaniment and Carey’s honeyed vocals, as candy as pecan pie. As Carey sings on the glowing monitor, “The dream is to share this Christmas cheer with you all yr, and never wait until the morning when Christmas time is within the air once more.”

Carey has by no means been shy about her religion — see The Emancipation of Mimi’s “Fly Like a Chook” or the overtly gospel stylings of “Heavenly (No Methods Drained / Can’t Give Up Now)” from 2014’s Me. I Am Mariah… The Elusive Chanteuse — however her debut Christmas album marked one of many first instances the big-voiced singer was in a position to actually let unfastened and lean into her religious aspect. Whereas album nearer “Jesus, Oh What a Great Baby” raises the refrain to the rafters, it’s the poignant “Jesus Born on This Day” that basically showcases the rationale for the season. Backed by a kids’s choir and Carey’s impassioned supply, the track begins out like a modern-day hymn earlier than ascending right into a full-on testomony of reward. The story of Christmas has by no means sounded so divine.

‘O Holy Evening’ is a kind of Christmas carols that many singers try, however few can do justice. Carey one way or the other manages to not solely conquer the track but in addition make it her personal. Right here, the Queen of Christmas can also be the Queen of Melisma, diving into every observe with abandon and zeal. An instrumental break provides the diva simply sufficient time to regular her vocals, earlier than the track is swept up in a grand finale of whistle tones and belts that takes the hymn to the heavens. In the case of ‘O Holy Evening,’ Carey’s model soars above the remainder.

“We’d like pleasure greater than ever,” Carey proclaimed on the Los Angeles cease of her 2024 “Christmas Time Tour,” which occurred simply days after Donald Trump gained the election. Although Carey has stayed largely out of the political fray, she adopted up her assertion with a rousing rendition of this traditional Christmas tune, which the singer transforms from church staple to club-ready anthem. Carey grunts, growls and powers her approach by means of the 4 minute-long monitor, displaying off her multi-octave voice whereas a backing choir provides a contact of gospel enchantment. Whether or not you’ve had a yr to neglect, or are partying it up, Carey’s model of “Pleasure to the World” brings good tidings to us all.

At its core, “All I Need for Christmas” is a wistful track, with Carey lamenting the considered one other vacation spent alone. Although it’s typically interpreted as a love track, the lyrics to the singer’s perennial chart topper share extra in frequent with a melancholic ballad, telling the story of somebody who’s determined for her sweetheart to return dwelling. “I don’t care concerning the presents beneath the Christmas tree,” she wails, “Santa gained’t you please convey my child to me?”

The identical sentiment echoes by means of “Miss You Most (At Christmas Time),” a solemn and tender standout from Carey’s best-selling Merry Christmas album. The confessional lyrics learn like diary pages — “All people’s smiling, the entire world is rejoicing, and everybody’s embracing apart from you and I,” Carey coos — and the singer’s supply carries the phrases with emotional nuance fairly than bombast. It’s some of the lovely songs Carey has ever written, with a heartfelt message that’s all too relatable at the moment of yr. “All I Need for Christmas” could also be her vacation anthem, however this crestfallen carol reveals that Carey might be on the prime of her recreation, whether or not festive or forlorn.